That’s why Consumer Reports, known for its unbiased testing and detailed reviews, remains a go-to source for mattress recommendations.
We’ve gone through their latest findings to bring you the top 10 mattresses that scored high for comfort, durability, and overall value.
Whether you’re a side sleeper, a hot sleeper, or someone who just wants the best balance between plush and firm, this list is a great place to start.
1. Saatva Classic (Luxury Firm)
Why it made the list: Saatva’s innerspring-hybrid design offers a plush Euro-top feel without sacrificing support. Its dual-coil system gives it exceptional durability, making it a great choice for long-term use.
Best for: Back and stomach sleepers who want a luxury hotel bed feel.
2. Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Adapt
Why it made the list: Known for its iconic memory foam, Tempur-Pedic continues to dominate in pressure relief. Consumer Reports praised its ability to cradle the body without overheating.
Best for: Side sleepers and those with joint pain.
3. Avocado Green Mattress
Why it made the list: This eco-friendly mattress uses organic latex, wool, and cotton. CR testers noted its supportive feel and impressive durability, along with its sustainability credentials.
Best for: Eco-conscious shoppers who like a medium-firm feel.
4. Stearns & Foster Estate Rockwell
Why it made the list: A premium innerspring option with exceptional edge support and cooling features. It’s also praised for motion isolation—ideal for couples.
Best for: Hot sleepers and those sharing a bed.
5. Purple Mattress
Why it made the list: Purple’s unique Hyper-Elastic Polymer grid offers a different kind of support—springy, cool, and pressure-relieving. CR reviewers found it adapts well to different sleeping positions.
Best for: Combination sleepers and people who dislike sinking too deeply.
6. Sleep Number 360 i8 Smart Bed
Why it made the list: Adjustable firmness at the touch of a button and sleep tracking features set this one apart. CR called it a good choice for couples with different firmness preferences.
Best for: Couples and tech enthusiasts.
7. Casper Original Hybrid
Why it made the list: Combining foam layers with pocketed coils, the Casper Hybrid offers balanced support and cushioning. CR noted its above-average durability for the price.
Best for: Budget-conscious buyers who still want premium comfort.
8. Helix Midnight Luxe
Why it made the list: Custom-tailored for side sleepers, this mattress combines memory foam with zoned coils for targeted pressure relief. CR testers highlighted its excellent spinal alignment.
Best for: Side sleepers needing extra shoulder and hip cushioning.
9. WinkBed Luxury Firm
Why it made the list: Known for its handcrafted quality, the WinkBed blends innerspring support with a plush pillow top. Consumer Reports rated it highly for both durability and cooling.
Best for: People seeking a balance of softness and firm support.
10. Beautyrest Black Original
Why it made the list: A top performer in support and motion isolation, this luxury innerspring mattress also features advanced cooling technology.
Best for: Hot sleepers and couples who want minimal motion transfer.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right mattress is personal—it depends on your sleep style, comfort preferences, and even your room’s climate. The good news? All of these mattresses scored well in Consumer Reports’ rigorous testing for comfort, durability, and satisfaction. If you’ve been putting off replacing your old bed, this list might be the nudge you need.
